Sapphire Engagement Rings vs Diamond Engagement Rings
Choosing between sapphire engagement rings vs diamond engagement rings is more than picking a gem. It’s about understanding beauty, meaning, and tradition—values at the heart of Shreve & Co. since 1852.
Diamonds: Timeless Brilliance and Endurance
Diamonds are a symbol of forever. With unmatched hardness (a 10 on the Mohs scale), they’re built to last through generations. Their clear sparkle is associated with purity and enduring love, making them the traditional choice for engagement rings.
Their brilliance comes from their ability to reflect light in all directions. This is why diamond engagement rings remain the most popular worldwide. Whether in solitaire or halo settings, diamonds offer a classic, refined elegance.
Their brilliance comes from their ability to reflect light in all directions. This is why diamond engagement rings remain the most popular worldwide. Whether in solitaire or halo settings, diamonds offer a classic, refined elegance.
Sapphires: Colorful, Unique, and Meaningful
Sapphires are a stunning alternative, loved for their bold colors and deep symbolism. Blue is the most well-known shade, but sapphires also come in pink, yellow, and green. They rank 9 on the Mohs scale, making them nearly as durable as diamonds.
These stones symbolize loyalty, truth, and wisdom. A sapphire ring expresses individuality while still honoring tradition. It’s the perfect choice for someone who wants something meaningful and just a little different.
These stones symbolize loyalty, truth, and wisdom. A sapphire ring expresses individuality while still honoring tradition. It’s the perfect choice for someone who wants something meaningful and just a little different.
The Influence of History and Royalty
Diamonds have been admired for centuries, but their dominance in engagement rings grew in the 20th century. The iconic phrase “A diamond is forever” helped solidify their role in proposals around the globe.
Sapphires, on the other hand, are known as the gem of royalty. Princess Diana’s sapphire ring—now worn by Kate Middleton—is one of the most famous engagement rings in modern history. Its elegance inspired a new generation of sapphire lovers.
Sapphires, on the other hand, are known as the gem of royalty. Princess Diana’s sapphire ring—now worn by Kate Middleton—is one of the most famous engagement rings in modern history. Its elegance inspired a new generation of sapphire lovers.
Aesthetics: Brilliance vs. Color
Diamond rings are loved for their brilliance and sparkle, which result from precision cutting. The most common styles, such as round, cushion, and princess cuts, are designed to maximize light reflection.
Sapphires offer richness of color instead. A royal blue sapphire surrounded by diamonds creates a dramatic, eye-catching look. Their charm lies not in sparkle, but in their deep and saturated tones.
Pricing and Value Considerations
One of the main differences in sapphire engagement rings vs diamond engagement rings is price. High-quality diamonds are generally more expensive per carat, due to their demand and strict grading systems.
Sapphires, while still luxurious, can offer a larger or more vibrant stone at a lower cost. For couples looking for a budget-friendly yet striking ring, sapphires are a smart and stylish alternative.
Designer Settings Make the Difference
Shreve & Co. features world-class designers who specialize in both diamonds and sapphires. For brilliant-cut diamonds, explore Hearts On Fire or JB Star. For artistic sapphire creations, discover Paolo Costagli or Sethi Couture.
Settings play a big role in enhancing a gemstone’s beauty. Sapphires shine in vintage and halo styles, while diamonds fit seamlessly in solitaires or pavé bands. Our experts help you match stone and setting flawlessly.
Mixing Diamonds and Sapphires
Can’t decide? You don’t have to. Many couples now combine the two. A sapphire center with a diamond halo, or a diamond center accented with sapphire side stones, offers the best of both worlds.
This combination blends tradition with creativity. At Shreve & Co., you can work with our consultants to create a custom design that reflects your story and personal style.
Durability for Everyday Life
Both diamonds and sapphires are highly durable. Diamonds are the hardest natural substance on earth, ideal for those with active lifestyles. Sapphires are second only to diamonds and perform well with regular wear.
Whichever you choose, proper care is essential. Shreve & Co. offers professional cleaning and maintenance services to keep your engagement ring sparkling for years to come.
Ethical Sourcing and Peace of Mind
Modern couples care about where their gems come from. At Shreve & Co., we partner with designers who support ethical sourcing and conflict-free stones—whether you choose a sapphire or a diamond.
We also offer lab-grown diamonds, which are more sustainable and often more affordable. This gives you ethical options without sacrificing beauty or quality.
Sentimental and Heirloom Value
A ring is more than a piece of jewelry—it’s a family legacy. Both sapphire and diamond rings can become treasured heirlooms. Many Shreve & Co. rings are passed down through generations, each carrying stories of love and tradition.
Choosing a timeless design ensures your ring stays meaningful and stylish through the years. Our rich history of craftsmanship supports your journey from proposal to forever.
Sizing and Comfort Considerations
Both types of stones can be set in a variety of ring styles, from slim bands to bold settings. The choice of band width, prong type, and ring height also affects comfort. Our team will guide you through each option during your visit.
Custom sizing and complimentary consultations are part of the Shreve & Co. experience. We ensure that your ring not only looks stunning, but also fits like a dream.
Shreve & Co.: A Legacy of Love
Since 1852, Shreve & Co. has helped generations find engagement rings that speak to the heart. We bring heritage, precision, and passion to every piece we offer—whether it features a sapphire, a diamond, or both.
Located in Palo Alto, our showroom is home to an exceptional collection of luxury timepieces, fine jewelry, and exclusive engagement rings. We welcome you to explore and discover your perfect match.
Discover the best Engagement Rings here at Shreve & Co. in the Bay Area, CA.
When it comes to sapphire engagement rings vs diamond engagement rings, the best choice is the one that reflects your personality and values. Both stones offer beauty, meaning, and long-lasting joy.
At Shreve & Co., we’re here to help you navigate the decision with confidence and clarity. Let us guide you toward a ring that’s as unique and timeless as your love story.
Visit us at Stanford Shopping Center in Palo Alto. And, don’t forget to follow us on Instagram and Facebook to keep up with our latest news and get some stunning jewelry inspiration.
At Shreve & Co., we’re here to help you navigate the decision with confidence and clarity. Let us guide you toward a ring that’s as unique and timeless as your love story.
Visit us at Stanford Shopping Center in Palo Alto. And, don’t forget to follow us on Instagram and Facebook to keep up with our latest news and get some stunning jewelry inspiration.
